Being Jewish in New Zealand and the concerning rise of antisemitism | North & South

Juliet Moses

Growing up in Auckland, I knew I was a bit different.

Christmas wasn’t a big deal for me. My family didn’t have a Christmas tree and a wreath on our door, and 25 December was the most boring day of the year. Often, we would travel to a holiday destination on that day. Once, we excitedly discovered the movies were on, and had pretty much the entire theatre to ourselves.

Around Easter, my customary school lunchbox sandwiches got replaced with thin, dry tasteless crackers that my friends would ask to try, but only once.

On Sunday mornings, I begrudgingly went to a special school – listening to Bad Jelly the Witch on the radio as we carpooled there – where I learned a script we read from right to left. Sometimes I would use words I thought were part of every family’s lexicon, but when I was greeted with blank stares I realised they were Yiddish. When the subject of World War II came up, or what was happening in the world, I often sensed a raw and bitter pain in my grandmother.

Yes, I knew I was a bit different, but I was proud to be Jewish. My family, although not religious, was observant. I had a bat mitzvah (a coming-of-age ceremony) when I turned 13. Some of the highlights of the year for me were the Jewish festivals, when we took a day off school to attend synagogue and gather together with close family friends for a ceremonial dinner that included much rowdiness and hilarity.

Read more

Abbas: Elections for you but not for me | AIR

Palestinian Authority Mahmoud Abbas was elected in January 2005 and is in the fifteenth year of his “four-year” term, so you’d think the last thing his Fatah party would want to do is call more attention to the fact that Palestinians have not had any elections since 2006.  But you’d be wrong.

Ahead of the September 17 Israeli election, Fatah’s Facebook page posted 11 different posters calling on Arabs to vote — in Israel.

Among the slogans promoted on the page by Fatah were “Your representation in the Knesset will work to restore yoru status — VOTE!” and “Your vote — your future” and “Please note:  If you do not vote your vote will go to the [Israeli] right.”

This message was also pervasive in Palestinian Authority (PA) media, including PA-aligned newspapers.  One day before the election, an article in the newspaper  Al-Hayat al-Jadida  by Muhammad Ali Taha read “Avoiding [Arab] voting is [Israeli PM Binyamin] Netanyahu’s goal because he is scared of the Arab vote, so go down to the polls and contribute to his downfall.”

In the same paper, columnist Omar Halmi al-Ghul wrote “Non-voting works for the benefit of the Zionist colonial forces… So we should all demand that our public vote and participate massively.”

The irony of calling for Arabs in Israel to vote while their own people in the West Bank have not had an election in almost a decade and a half has not been lost on Palestinians.  They have reportedly been flooding social media with responses along the lines of — “They should vote?  What about us?”  and ending their posts with the trending hashtag (in Arabic): #wewantelections.

Source:  Australia-Israel Review, October 2019, page 11.

Israel could get an Unity Government |AIR

While the make up of Israel’s next government remains unclear, what was striking in the aftermath of the September 17 election is that Israel’s democracy remains alive and feisty.

firstly, despite an unprecedented second election within five months and widespread predictions of higher voter apathy, voter turnout increased 2% from April’s poll to around 69%.

Secondly, Arab-Israelis showed their desire to participate in Israel’s democratic process. Bouncing back from a low turnout in April, approximately 10% more Arab Israelis voted this time around.

Moreover, highlighting the absurdity of critics alleging “apartheid” in Israel, the Arab-dominated Joint List now holds the third-largest number of seats in the Knesset (13, up from 10), is an active participant in the horse trading to form a new government, and its head, Ayman Odeh, may possibly become the country’s official opposition leader.

Thirdly, ultra-orthodox party Otzma Yehudit, followers of the late extremist Rabbi Meir Kahane, again failed to win any seats – a welcome outcome for a party whose extremism and racism deserve no place in the Israeli mainstream.

Meanwhile, the results — Blue and White winning 33 seats, Likud with 31 — have seen most commentators agree that a national unity government is the most likely outcome of the coalition negotiations which follow any Israeli election. This may also be a good outcome.

Unity governments have frequently governed Israel in the past and the results have been mixed. Some broad-based coalition governments have become virtually paralysed with infighting. However, unity governments have also served Israel well at times of grave national challenge, such as the Six Day War in 1967, or the hyper-inflation crisis of the mid-80s.

Today, there are grave and persistent security threats to Israel from the north and Gaza — all of which derive from Iran and its local proxies. While these threats are not new, there is good reason to believe that they are reaching a critical turning point — suggesting that a united government reaching across the political spectrum might be the best way for Israel to confront these challenges.

Source: Rubinstein, C (October 2019). Australia Israel Review. Page 4. Abridge.

Cumin v Minto public debate: recording available

On October 3, David Cumin (Israel Institute of NZ) and John Minto (Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa), met in a highly anticipated debate over Differing Perspectives of Israel. 

Held at the University of Auckland, it attracted a full house of some 170; so full that people filled the area around the podium.

Well moderated by Rosslyn Noonan, NZ’s former Human Rights Commissioner, the deep feeling of each debater’s supporters threatened to break out into chaos at times. 

Minto idealistically promoted a one-state solution where both Arab and Jew enjoyed the rights of democratic citizenship in peace. 

Cumin supported a two-state solution where both peoples could seek self-determination.  Having said that it looked like he didn’t believe this had much chance of ever succeeding as Arab leaders continue to seek a “river to the sea” solution.

The first public debate on Israel in many years, it served as a release valve for many of the pent up emotions evoked by the issue. 

Hopefully there will be further loan opportunities for public discourse, each one perhaps more focused on different aspects of the many-facted issue. 

A video recording of the event and each debater’s opening remarks may be found here.

Ask Me Anything with R Ariel Tal recordings available now

Rabbi Ariel Tal

Last September, Christchurch members were treated to an Ask Me Anything session with Rabbi Ariel Tal of the Wellington Jewish Community Centre.

An enthusiastic and engaging speaker, the crowd were quickly fascinated and intrigued with his answers to questions relating to himself, Judaism and what it is like to live as a Jew in New Zealand.

We’re pleased to announce the video recording of the event is now available. A separate audio file is also available in the same folder. Many thanks to David Allen for making the recordings.

Shana tova!

A new Hebrew year begins at sundown on Sunday evening, goodbye 5779, roll on 5780.

Shana tova to all! May the New Year bring you much joy and happiness

From everyone at NZ Friends of Israel

Is antisemitism on the rise once again? | Radio NZ

Dr Deborah Lipstadt

Dr Deborah Lipstadt has spent her life studying hate – specifically, the hatred of Jews. The Atlanta-based historian and author wrote about antisemitism in her 1993 book ‘Denying the Holocaust’ and found herself sued by British author and Holocaust denier David Irving for libel.

She won the case in part by providing evidence at the lengthy judge-only trial that the Holocaust happened, with a focus on the existence and use of gas chambers and a coordinated Nazi plan directed by Hitler. Her trial was made into a movie in 2016 called ‘Denial’.  Dr Lipstadt has published a new book this year called ‘Antisemitism Here and Now’ arguing that acts and expressions of antisemitism are on the rise again.

Source

CHRISTCHURCH: Sonia Waters: August 25 | LWCC

NZFOI: For those interested in the relationship between Judaism and Christianity.

New director of basketball Dan Shamir shares vision for new-look NZ Breakers | NewsHub

NZFOI: Nice to see the BDS crowd weren’t successful in preventing Shamir’s appointment.

With the start of the new ANBL season almost two months away, NZ Breakers newly appointed director of basketball Dan Shamir has ensured he’s settled, and ready to tackle both a new culture and a new club.

Shamir touched down on New Zealand soil from his native Israel with his family at the start of July to begin the complex process of getting the four-time champions back on the track to title contention after some lean years, with just two playoffs appearances through their past five campaigns.

That challenge – combined with the chance for him and his young family to experience a new lifestyle down under – were Shamir’s primary motivations in the decision to accept the position on a three-year term.

“This is a very unique place,” Shamir told Newshub. “It’s a place with some kind of special energy.

“I’ve been told from the first moment that I’m going to meet a lot of good people and that’s happened.”

Read more

NZ, Israel and UNRWA w/ Stephen Hoadley | 95BFM

Associate Professor Stephen Hoadley, University of Auckland

NZFOI: After interviewing John Minto, 95BFM was criticized for a lack of balance in their interview of John Minto. In response to that criticism, the station interviewed Associate Professor Stephen Hoadley, a lecturer in International Relations from the University of Auckland.

You can listen to it here.