
– A slanted take on life there
You would have thought that the collaboration between a Northern Irishman and his Republican counterpart (Garry Keane and Andrew McConnell) would yield a truthful insight into Gaza, that tiny 40km by 11km strip. They, after all, know what it’s like to come from different sides of a conflict, the importance of showing life accurately and should well know how “The Troubles” ended. Alas no. The documentary brief as outlined in the Doc Edge festival, was to show real life in Gaza, not just shapshots of war. In that they do in part, but without crucial explanation of key elements and all set to a very emotive score. It’s a story that began when Andrew McConnell went to Gaza to photograph surfers, so the sea plays a key role.
What we see is a collection of vignettes on the lives of different inhabitants and events that happen. The cast of characters is extremely varied with a great deal of emphasis on children who roam about and the role of the sea in their varied lives. We meet a taxi driver, a fisherman, a frustrated tailor, a man with three wives and 40 children, a theatre director, a vain lifeguard, a wealthy family with a sensitive child, a handicapped rapper, a paramedic et al. Thematically the documentary explores how people cope, living in what former British PM David Cameron described as an “open air prison” with unemployment standing at 50%, only 4-5 hours of power a day and undrinkable water.
What makes this documentary poignant is the UN has declared Gaza uninhabitable by 2020 – well that’s next year. Many watching this documentary will miss the points being shown; especially as it ends with a targeted Israeli attack and the consequent injuries and destroyed buildings invalidating the stated purpose. Meantime here are some questions unanswered:
- Why is there no reference to the impact of the Eqyptian border closure?
- Why does Israel get the blame for this situation not of their making? They withdrew.
- Why is there a refugee camp in Gaza, aren’t they all the same people?
- Where is the money coming from for food and supplies if there is no work?
- Why are women wearing the Hijab when they didn’t previously?
- Why aren’t some of the children going to school?
- Why only 4-5 hours of power?
- Who is responsible for fixing the utilities?
- Why does Hamas engage in indiscriminate shooting in the streets?
- Why are they handing out sweets to the crowds after the prisoner is released?
- Rubbish is everywhere. Yet people are sitting around playing cards, not cleaning up things? Don’t they care for their country? Is it someone else’s responsibility?
- Why are there posters of Yasser Arafat?
- Why aren’t bombed buildings fixed so people can go and live there. Isn’t that why they need concrete and building materials, so where is it going? Tunnels perhaps?
- Are all fishermen innocent people just catching fish?
- Why are they burning tyres and harming their health on the Israeli border alone?
By ending with an Israeli bombing and its aftermath, the documentary can only lead you to blame Israel for all Gazan woes. Clearly, misleading.
About the Author: Joanna Moss is a writer, researcher and the NZFOI Wellington Regional Coordinator.