
Commemorations around the world have marked the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. An Auckland couple who survived the Holocaust are contributing to a global effort aimed at ensuring “never again” means just that.
NZ Friends of Israel Association Inc
Fighting racial intolerance in New Zealand and beyond
Commemorations around the world have marked the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. An Auckland couple who survived the Holocaust are contributing to a global effort aimed at ensuring “never again” means just that.
Two years ago, I was standing at sunset overlooking Wharariki Beach, appreciating one of the most picturesque scenes that I have ever seen, if not the most, when a man approached me. “Beautiful, isn’t it?” he said. “Incredible,” I replied. I asked him where he was from and he said he was from a suburb of London. He had come to this part of the world with his wife for their anniversary, to see what he described as “heaven on earth” with his own eyes. He asked me where I was from, and when I replied Israel, his wife, who was standing next to him went, “Ohhh.” I asked her what she meant.
She said she had a friend, when they lived in Portugal, an Israeli, who used to talk about Israel all the time when they used to have dinner together. She told me about how he used to go on and on about his army experiences, the wars he fought in, and the smell of the Machaneh Yehuda market in Jerusalem. When she finished, her husband said, “We visited there once; a beautiful country you have.” “Yes, it is,” I responded, “but it’s different.” He asked why, and in that split second, I then understood why at moments like these, while appreciating God’s breathtaking creations, I had missed home more in the few days I had been on summer break in New Zealand than all the time I had been working on shlichut in Australia so far.
“It’s different because in Israel everything has meaning behind it. Sure, God created the entire world, the incredible beach here, the beautiful fjords in the south, and the amazing sunset we’re looking at right now. But in Israel, there’s something behind each view that’s much deeper.” He asked me to specify what I was talking about.
So I told him about where I live, and the view I have from my front porch. The biblical significance of my community, and the fact I used to live on a street named for the spring underneath it, that used to run all the way to the Temple in Jerusalem. I told him about the prophecies of Ezekiel that are coming to pass in my backyard, and the most mentioned prophecy in the entire Old Testament, which I experienced first-hand, live, four and a half years ago while getting off a plane and kissing the asphalt. I told him that I learned for two and a half years in a place where there’s a town square emblazoned with a 2,000-year-old prophecy from Zecharia, of old men and women returning to sit and children returning to play in that very spot, and how the local schools make sure that they time their recesses so that the square will never be empty of playing children.
I explained to him how when I prayed there, I prayed overlooking the place where the Temple once stood and will soon again stand, just needing to look up from my prayer book through the window to envision what I was praying for. I tried to convey to him how when my cousin in Israel finished a portion of the Bible relating to the story of our forefathers, he celebrated with his classmates in the very tomb of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.
He was astounded by my response, and when saying farewell, commented to his wife “we must visit there again.”
When I returned from vacation back to Melbourne to start another year of trying to inspire all sorts of Jews from all different backgrounds to connect to Judaism and their homeland, many people in the community and friends asked me how my experience there was.
As I said to one of my friends who sarcastically joked based on my photos about me moving to New Zealand instead of coming back to Israel in August: There are two kinds of beauty in this world. Inner beauty and outer beauty, or in Hebrew יופי פנימי and יופי חיצוני. Many times over the trip I came to a viewpoint and saw something so incredibly beautiful that it caused me to just throw up my hands in the air and say “מה רבו מעשיך ה”, but even at those times I felt that something was missing when feeling the longing I had for Israel. Because the awe-inspiring forms of nature that I witnessed there may very well be some of the most beautiful scenes I will ever see, but the word “beautiful” here is only referring to the outer beauty, the יופי חיצוני. True beauty is composed of both inner and outer beauty. In other words, external beauty and meaning.
That doesn’t mean that I won’t travel to see the wonders of God, and try to witness landscapes that will increase my awe of heaven—spectacles so impressive that they will inspire me to spontaneously pray to God. But everything in life is perspective.
I may never see a more beautiful landscape of waterfalls running down the side of a mountain as I saw at the Rob Roy Glacier in Wanaka, but the mountain itself is empty. It’s a creation of God just like anything else in the world, but its holiness is limited.
And most of all, it isn’t mine. It wasn’t promised to my nation and myself by God.
It’s beautiful. But it isn’t truly beautiful.
Doni Cohen, 24, made aliyah from Bergenfield, NJ, to Efrat in July 2013. He did hesder in Yeshivat HaKotel, serving in Tzahal as a commander in the Military Rabbinate, did a year of shlichut through “Torah MiTzion” in Melbourne, Australia. He’s currently studying political science, Jewish history and contemporary Jewry in Hebrew University on Mount Scopus while working on various non-profit projects. He has written for and his aliyah story has been featured in various tri-state-area papers and he can be contacted at arbel67@gmail.com.
New Zealand has had a patchy history with the Holocaust. With a recent resurgence in antisemitism, it’s time we stepped up efforts to ensure it’s given no ground here.
The dust is settling after a flurry of commemorative events and articles, locally and internationally, marking the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. In the days leading up to UN International Holocaust Remembrance Day (January 27), the hashtag #WeRemember circulated on social media, with encouragement to contemplate that horrific period of history.
UN Holocaust Remembrance Day falls at the height of New Zealand’s summer holiday season, when sun and surf are uppermost in many Kiwi minds. So it’s hardly surprising that Holocaust commemoration commands relatively little attention. Of greater concern, however, is that according to a poll undertaken in July 2019, New Zealand appears to suffer Holocaust amnesia. The multi-choice survey revealed that only 43 percent of respondents knew that approximately six million Jews were killed in the Holocaust, 20 percent thought fewer were killed, 37 percent were unsure, and worryingly, 30 percent were unsure whether the Holocaust had been exaggerated or was a myth.
Read more: Trotter, S (3 Feb 2020). NZ must step up against anti-Semitism. Newsroom. www.newsroom.co.nz.
NZFOI: This article is remarkable in that it draws together evidence that there was significant sympathy for the Nazi Fascist philosophies of the 1930s. These sympathies were more widely held than the Western world would care to admit following the discovery of the death camps uncovered toward the end of WW2. Today few recall that in the early- to mid-1930s, the world was unsure as to what to make of Fascism and Communism. There were groups on both sides of the spectrum that recognized the potential for evil both these philosophies could unleash. Equally there many that thought that either one of these philosophies would bring the longed for prosperity and happiness that had eluded society for so long. But the silent majority were undecided and only saw immigrants and refugees as additional competitors for limited resources.
Last week the discovery of Nazi symbols sprayed outside a Wellington synagogue brought shock and condemnation. But New Zealand is no stranger to antisemitism. In light of increasing ignorance about the Holocaust, we need to revisit and acknowledge our history, writes Scott Hamilton.
Today is Holocaust Remembrance Day. Around the world, candles will be lit to honour the six and a quarter million Jews who died in Europe between 1933, when the Nazis took power in Germany, and 1945, when Hitler shot himself amid the ruins of Berlin. Last year a poll found that 29% of New Zealanders knew little or nothing about the Holocaust. When they were asked whether the Holocaust was a myth, a third of those polled either refused to respond or said they were unsure how to answer. Only 18% of young New Zealanders said they knew much about the Holocaust.
Giacomo Lichtner, an associate professor of history at Victoria University, wrote an op-ed on Stuff to explain why he was unsurprised by the findings of the poll. When he has tried to talk to New Zealanders about the Holocaust, Lichtner has often found Kiwis sceptical about the event’s relevance to their country. What, they wonder, could faraway New Zealand have had to do with the tragedy of the Jews in fascist Europe?
Eckhardt Reyneke didn’t think twice about quickly painting over swastikas graffitied outside a Jewish temple, calling it a “small deed”, but his actions have sparked tears of thanks.
Last week Wellington City Council received reports of graffiti in several locations on The Terrace and outside the Wellington Jewish Progressive Congregation on Ghuznee St.
Council contractors swiftly removed the graffiti from the various sites but when they got to Temple Sinai they found it had already been erased from the fence.
Reyneke, 20, was working on a construction site next door to the temple when his colleague noticed the swastikas while throwing away some rubbish.
In New Zealand, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern paid tribute to the millions who died during the Holocaust and declared anti-Semitism had no place in the world.
Ardern delivered the message at the Mount Eden War Memorial in Auckland last night to mark International Holocaust Remembrance Day .
Last night, Ms Ardern acknowledged the immeasurable loss of life and pain experienced by the Jewish community around the world.
This is the report mentioned in David Zwartz’s article “Why Holocaust Remembrance Day matters more than ever” published by Stuff, two days ago.
BBC reporter Richard Dimbleby was the first broadcaster to enter the Bergen-Belsen death camp after it was liberated by the British on April 15, 1945. Overcome, he broke down several times while making his report. The BBC initially refused to play it, as they could not believe the scenes he had described, and it was broadcast only after Dimbleby threatened to resign.
Bergen-Belsen was only one of the thousands of killing sites during World War II. The Holocaust saw the murder and death of six million European and North African Jews in a deliberate genocide.
Millions of others were targeted for their race, religion, gender, disabilities or political views. As Nobel peace laureate and Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel put it: “Not all victims were Jews, but all Jews were victims.”
Why do we remember such horrifying and tragic events 75 years later? There are many different reasons.’I stayed alive to tell’: Auschwitz’s dwindling survivors recount the horrorAhead of the 75 anniversary of the liberation of the Nazi concentration camp at Auschwitz, survivors have been talking about their memories three quarters of a century on.Share
‘I stayed alive to tell’: Auschwitz’s dwindling survivors recount the horror
Ahead of the 75 anniversary of the liberation of the Nazi concentration camp at Auschwitz, survivors have been talking about their memories three quarters of a century on.
Current UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres says: “It would be a dangerous error to think of the Holocaust as simply the result of the insanity of a group of criminal Nazis. On the contrary, the Holocaust was the culmination of millennia of hatred, scapegoating and discrimination targeting the Jews, what we now call antisemitism.”
The UN General Assembly resolved in 2005 that UN International Holocaust Remembrance Day (UNIHRD) would be on January 27 – the anniversary of the day in 1945 when the Red Army liberated the Auschwitz-Birkenau Nazi German concentration and extermination camp.
Acknowledging 2020 as a milestone year, the UN Outreach Programme has chosen a theme for UNIHRD that “reflects the continued importance, 75 years after the Holocaust, of collective action against antisemitism and other forms of bias to ensure respect for the dignity and human rights of all people everywhere”.
Jews feel deep personal sadness and anger over the murder of members of their whānau, and the injustice of continuing antisemitism.
Some say that the Holocaust is a uniquely Jewish tragedy, and we undermine Holocaust remembrance unless we concentrate on fighting antisemitism in all its different manifestations.
Other Jews, while not denying the uniqueness of the Holocaust, see antisemitism as a symptom of racism in whatever society or culture harbours it. They want to pursue a broader fight against racism, using the Jewish experience as a warning of what has happened in history, and can happen again to any minority ethnic and religious groups.
It is correct that antisemitism – “the longest hatred” – has been historically recorded for about 2500 years, and shows no sign of diminishing. It has mutated over the centuries through ethnic, religious and racial Jew-hatred to its contemporary, largely anti-Israel, versions. Present-day antisemitism, which is often violent and virulent, appears to be growing around the world – unchecked on social media in this country.
A recent NZ Human Rights Commission publication, Kōrero Whakamauāhara: Hate speech, opens by quoting Holocaust historian Deborah Lipstadt (known for winning the libel case brought against her by a UK Holocaust denier, as portrayed in the film Denial).
Lipstadt said: “When expressions of contempt for one group become normative, it is virtually inevitable that similar hatred will be directed at other groups. Like a fire set by an arsonist, passionate hatred and conspiratorial worldviews reach well beyond their intended target.”
Many Jews promote Holocaust education because the Holocaust was a significant event in Western history, and understanding it helps combat the concerns expressed by Lipstadt.
In the same way that Anzac Day does for all Kiwis, Holocaust commemoration fulfils a deep human commitment by Jews and all people to remember death and suffering, at the same time as looking forward to improve humanity’s future by changing societal attitudes.
Particularly since the March 15 massacre at the Christchurch mosques, Holocaust observance and education also promote well-being in New Zealand. They help the government, Human Rights Commission, major religious and interfaith groups and NGOs make this country fully aware of its endemic racism, and how to tackle it.
Since 2007, the Holocaust Centre of New Zealand (HCNZ) has been the country’s leading Holocaust education organisation. Its vision is “Through testimony, experience and advocacy, inspire and empower individuals to stand against prejudice, discrimination and apathy.”
HCNZ helped start the public commemoration of UNIHRD in Aotearoa New Zealand. UNIHRD is now observed annually in Auckland, Hamilton, Wellington and Christchurch, with civic and Unesco support.
While some Jews say bitterly, referring to continuing antisemitism, “What’s the use of remembering dead Jews when the world continues to behave so badly to living Jews?”, I think this is ungracious, and counter-productive; and invite everyone in the main centres who has good will and concern for our nation’s future to take part in the UNIHRD commemoration on Monday.
* David Zwartz is chairperson of the Wellington Regional Jewish Council. The Wellington UNIHRD ceremony will be at 1-2pm at the Holocaust Memorial, Makara Cemetery, on Monday, January 27.
NZFOI: Saddening, embarrassing, disappointing, and alarming.
The Race Relations Commissioner is calling on every New Zealander to reject the tactics and ideologies of hate groups after swastikas were spray-painted outside Temple Sinai in Wellington.
The Jewish community is on guard after fluorescent yellow swastikas also appeared in several other inner-city locations.
Wellington City Council received reports this morning of graffiti on different parts of the footpath on The Terrace and outside the Wellington Jewish Progressive Congregation on Ghuznee St. It has since been removed.
Photographs supplied to the Herald show swastikas were painted and the word “Heil”.
There are a number of ways you can support us in our fight against racial intolerance through raising awareness of Jewish history and culture.
We are looking for volunteer regional coordinators to organise regular meetings of supporters so that they can learn about Jewishness and Israel affairs.
Contact us to find out whether your region has a coordinator, and if you’re up for it, we can have a discussion about your background and relevant skill sets. We may also need to talk to some referees.
We are also currently raising funds toward:
Be sure to email us your contact details if you wish to receive a tax receipt: contact@nzfoi.org.
If you’re in New Zealand you can also make a donation or join up via internet banking to the following account:
Account name: NZ Friends of Israel Association Inc
Account number: 02 0820 0569411 000
Code: “Membership” or the project you are donating towards like “Billboards”
Particulars: your Initial and Surname
If you wish to become a member, put Membership in the Code field. It’s just NZD 40 per year. Then send an email to contact@nzfoi.org with your contact details so that we can send you our newsletter and other announcements.
If you wish to receive a tax receipt, then email us at contact@nzfoi.org with the details of your donation and contact details. We’ll cross check it against our bank records and if it all corroborates, then we’ll issue you with a tax receipt.
Under Inland Revenue rules: Tax receipts are only available for donations not for membership or donations earmarked for overseas projects or causes.
——————–
NZ Friends of Israel Association Inc
P O Box 37 363
Christchurch
New Zealand 8245
M +64 (27) 433 9745
E contact@nzfoi.org
W www.nzfoi.org
NZ Charities Registration Number: CC 43880